Monday, March 9, 2015

No good byes in state

El Dorado's basketball teams said goodbye to their seasons Monday. Actually, that's a misnomer. There's no such thing as a good bye.
Well, perhaps in football, a bye isn't the worst thing in the world. Most teams welcome an open date during such a grueling season.
But, in the sport of basketball, teams that are awarded a bye in the state tournament can usually wave bye, bye, bye to their seasons.
First of all, there shouldn't be any byes in a state tournament. It's supposed to the best of the best all playing on equal ground to see who reigns supreme. For that reason alone, byes should be eliminated from the 6A and 7A Basketball State Tournaments in Arkansas.
Here's the other obvious reason, it's a huge disadvantage.
In the 6A Tournament Monday night in Siloam Springs, eight teams took the floor after having a first-round bye. Four of those eight teams were upset.
That included El Dorado's boys, who battled for a good seed all season only to come out flat and fall to Russellville 85-61. The Cyclones, of course, had a state-tournament game under their belt and entered the game on a high. The Wildcats, meanwhile, had the normal jitters of taking the floor for the first time in the big tournament. Throw in the fact they hadn't played in about 10 days due to the weather cancellations and, well, when you think about it, it really wasn't that much of an upset.
Parkview's top-ranked boys also fell victim to the bye, falling to No. 6 seed Pine Bluff 49-48.
On the girls side, top-seeded Little Rock Hall lost to Jonesboro 69-60 and Mountain Home awoke from its bye to find the host Siloam Springs looking down at the Lady Bombers after a 46-26 stunner. Hell, Greenwood was supposed to be a heavy favorite and had to rally from five down in the final minute to beat Benton 55-54.
I'm not trying to sell any of the winners short. That's kind of the point. Having a bye and then playing a poor team isn't a big deal. But, playing a good team that is coming off a win while you've been sitting at home or in a hotel room is simply not a fair fight.
El Dorado girls coach Stephen Harshaw said so before the state tournament. Although the Lady Wildcats fell to Parkview 50-41 Monday, Harshaw felt good about his team's chance because they did not have a bye.
Arkansas Activities Association, are you listening? Having a bye in the state tournament is such a big advantage that nobody wants it.
What are the solutions, you say? There are only 16 schools in Class 6A. Do we let everybody in?
No, we don't.
But, why doesn't Class 6A play two conference tournaments? The four semifinalists in each conference advance to play in an 8-team state tournament. Play the conference tournaments the same week the smaller classes compete in their regional tournaments.
I'm sure there are a million reasons this won't work so I'll sit back and let you throw 'em at me. Hey, I'm just trying to find a solution because one thing is for certain - we need to say goodbye to byes in the state tournament.

3 comments: